Receiving Holy Communion & Catholic Annulments

Here is a situation. We have a friend who’s husband and father of their five children has decided to walk away from his family and start a new family with a woman half his age that he had an ongoing affair with.

Both our friend’s Priest and myself told her that she was still able to receive Holy Communion, because, at the time I gave her this advice, she was still hopeful that their Marriage would work out.

But, since then her husband has moved in with and has had two more children with the mistress.

Three months ago, they legally divorced (his wishes not hers). This was three years coming.

A few weeks ago, she told us that she had met a “Catholic” man who is also recently divorced and neither of them have sought an Annulment as of yet (and that is not to say that both, one, or either will be granted a decree of nullification).

Our friend asked my Wife if she can still receive Holy Communion. His Priest says no, her Priest says Yes. Maybe @CanadianPriest has some input, though I know he is limited to what he can say, as he knows neither of these two parties.

My response was that as long as this new guy and she are just companions (going on hikes and spending time together, forming a friendship, and not getting serious) she can still receive (assuming she is in the state of grace).

However, I think she is moving too quickly and there are red flags with this man. I have not met the man, and I am simply going off of what she has told us about him, but he has been Married twice. He has one teenage son. My Wife has tried snooping on his Facebook profile, but he is either not very active on there or you must be friends with him to see more of his posts. It would be kind of suspicious if we requested to be his friend prior to meeting him.

They have gone to Mass together a few times. He has rightly abstained from receiving, per his Priest’s pastoral care, as his case is slightly different than hers, though similar.

I am posting this question to help others who may be in a similar situation to help them take the right steps moving forward from an awful predicament.

This is a very sad situation, and I feel very sorry that your friend and her children have gone through this.

As you have suggested, I am reticent to contradict the advice of any priest on the ground who may know the situation better than me.

The advice you gave her when her husband left her seems good. After all, he was the one who chose to leave.

What I will say about the current situation is that whether they should receive Holy Communion or not will depend very much on the nature of their relationship.

It is possible that they are just really good friends, in which case they may be certain dangers present, but that does not necessarily preclude reception of Holy Communion.

But of course, there can be other considerations.

2 Likes

Dang lol. So glad I don’t know people who do that. It boggles my mind how a lot of people, when they get married, recite their marriage vows and then decide on a whim to not keep them. Why in the heck are you getting married if you have trouble keeping your vows? Why are you having (or had) children with the person you married only to have an affair with someone else?

It’s honestly not that hard to admit that you have commitment issues. I know I do lol. I don’t date anyone anymore, nor am I fornicating, but I know for a fact if I was to get married at this point in my life, I’d be such a horrible husband. I have issues trying to care for myself, and I do have commitment issues. It’s one of the reasons why I never make plans, for the simple fact that I never really follow up with those plans, and yeah it’s sad, but I’m just being truthful lol. I’m a spontaneous kind of person. I’m the kind of person who will go to a gas station at 12:30 at night just to get a soda or a sandwich.

I feel like society places so much pressure on men and women alike to get married. Because you see these shows of people who are married, and they put these people on reality t.v. shows where it shows men and women cheating on eachother, and it’s just really sad. There is value to being single. There is a purpose out there for single people.

But, then again lol, I’ve never actually fit in with society (and when you think about it, I’m really not supposed to). The only person I have to answer to is God anyways…

1 Like