Private Revelation will never trump Public Revelation

  • True
  • False
  • I don’t know
0 voters

I rarely believe private revalation.

1 Like

that would be a mistake as well, Paul clearly says to test all prophecy and not to quench the Spirit…often, when one has gotten deep into Mental Prayer, you will start to notice little nudges or events during the day that show God is speaking…Bill Wilson, the founder of AA, even mentions this in the Big Book…

2 Likes

Peace to all,

To me, logic helps understand the mind of God from created, failed from the spirit through the souls of all created bodies in the flesh becoming again One Holy Spirit Family One God in being.

Spirit and life becomes through two, both natures becoming again in One Holy Spirit Body.

Peace always,
Stephen

is this private or public revelation?

"Moses, Samuel, Isaiah, etc., that would be considered ‘private revelation’”: I think that the books of the Bible are public revelation, part of the “deposit of faith.” The Catholic Catechism says, “There have been so-called “private” revelations, some of which have been recognized by the authority of the Church. They do not belong, however, to the deposit of faith.”

2 Likes

The Wikipedia page on Maria Valtorta says, " In 2025, the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith declared her writings as non-supernatural in origin. " It has a link to a Vatican press release of 22 Feb 2025.

1 Like

What happens when one’s private revelation contradicts public revelation. Which do you believe to be true?

The problem that I have with private revelation is that individuals who claim to be prophets today are mentally off (And maybe I would have thought the same of Moses, Samuel, Isaiah, etc. had I lived in their day.) Take for instance someone who believes God is telling them to blow up an abortion clinic, but public revelations tells us that this is wrong. Who is correct? I side with public revelation.

I do not doubt that God speaks to individuals. I believe He has guided my life, through others, signs, situations and opportunities. These were meant for me and not for the entire world. It isn’t that I am special, but rather that these revelations were not meant for everyone, but customized to my relationship with Him.

God knows who the leaders are. If He has a public message meant for everyone, He knows not to come to me ; )

Great point! I agree with this. I appreciate you sharing.

Vol. 1, p. 7, oddly claims, “Mary can be called the ‘second-born’ of the Father . . .” Her explanation limits the meaning, avoiding evidence of an authentic heresy; but it does not take away the basic impression that she wants to construct a new mariology, which simply goes beyond the limits of propriety." “Another strange and imprecise statement” made of Mary (vol. 4, p. 240) is that she will "be second to Peter with regard to ecclesiastical hierarchy. . . " Our Lady surpasses St. Peter’s holiness, but she is not in the hierarchy, let alone second to St. Peter.

Peace to all,

What Maria is trying to say is bland truthfully, nonlogical.

Logically, Mary preexisted as Queen of Heaven, Mother of God before creation was ever created was ven created, and the New Eve through the Annunciation becoming the Immaculate Conception for the Virgin Birth of The Christ becoming again in all mankind One Holy Spirit Family One God in being through both natures, spirit and flesh. Presented so Even a child can understand the Mind of God logically.

Saint Peter is Earthly Priestly Authority who now sits on Moses seat passing the keys to all understanding the revelation Jesus, in The Christ, The Entire Holy Spirit Family, The Father, and The Mother and The Son are One God in being is God in all mankind becoming again to currently Pope Francis, Vicar of Christ on Earth and the hanpicked of God to lead the Church.

Mary was born of Eve and becomes the New Eve through a singular, spectacular grace from God, a grace freely given becoming immaculate immortality through the Power of Holy Spirit Family through the New Eve for all Baptized into the Catholic Church and sanctified, flesh and spirit from the Holy Spirit and un-Confirmed in the Will of the Father and through The Christ becoming able to through Baptism from death to life to become again Confirmed and re-Sanctified glorified and transfigured through the Christ, bypassing death for Her Glorious Assumption, OMNILogically.

Logically, Always confusion reigns witout proper logic, OMNILogically God. The Forefathers and Foremothers of the Faith always miss on logic in the Trinity and not seeing The Trinity as One Holy Family and miss on logic of the preexistion Mother of God, Mary and not realizing the Holy Spirit Family is One God in being through three powers and personal Gods preexistion before creation From the Father through The Mother for The Son becoming the Christ, from the cross where the real blood and water rebirth became for all in all becoming again One Holy Spirit Family One God in being, OMNILogically.

Truthfully, rationally, and faithfully, Where did all of the blood and water even come from, He was Dead, no Jesus never dies, not of the Holy Spirit, rebirth for all through both natures, Holy Spirit and Immaculate Immortal Flesh becoming again One Holy Spirit Family One God in being, OMNILogically.

Peace always,
Stephen
Deliverer of the OMNILogical God, the same God from The Faith of Abraham explessed in the logic for today.

I merely reported what I discovered. Until yesterday I had not heard of Maria Valtorta. I do not have an opinion about her or her writing, nor do I have an obligation or an inclination to investigate claimed private revelations.

1 Like

“I do not doubt that God speaks to individuals. I believe He has guided my life, through others, signs, situations and opportunities. These were meant for me and not for the entire world.” I have had the same experience. One example: a few years ago I was praying with others outside an abortion clinic. A man was yelling at us and being kind of nasty. I thought I heard the Holy Spirit tell me that the man had lost a child to abortion, so I asked the guy whether he had lost a son or daughter to abortion. He said yes and said he wasn’t sorry. Did I have a private revelation? Did I make a lucky guess? Was I Captain Obvious, stating what anybody could figure out? I don’t know. It doesn’t matter. What matters is that I politely said something.

2 Likes

Peace to all,

As far as the Trinity, three persons in One God, logocally.

Rationally how can the Holy Spirit be a person and not a Holy Family of God and how can the Holy Family One God in being be without the Mother.

Peace always,
Stephen

Peace to all,

All of What Maria is trying to say is bland truthfully, but nonlogical including Fr. Mitch Pacwa’s article.

Logically Jesus is Eternal Priestly Authority of Spirit and Life and St. Peter now sits on Moses’ Seat and is Earthly Priestly Authority passing the Keys to Pope Francis, the Vicar of Christ on Earth, handpicked by God.

In all generalization and truthfully logically The Holy Spirit is a Family of God rationally and Mary existed in fulfilled intelligence logic as Queen of Heaven and Mother of God, God of Mercy before creation was ever created was even created, OMNILogically. And intelligently, physically and faithfully through the Immaculate Conception and The New Eve all mankind is transformed into immortality becoming again through The Christ incorruptibly glorified and transfigured One Holy Spirit Family One God in being.

Reasonably, really, Mary is from Adam and Eve, from the Power of The Holy Spirit at the Annunciation becoming the New Eve through the Immortal flesh in the Immaculate Conception delivering through Virgin Birth Jesus cenceived by the Holy Spirit Family from the New Adam becoming the Christ in all mankind becoming again through The Transfiguration just like Our Brother Jesus in all mankind glorified and transfigured One Holy Spirit Family One God in being.

Mary is the Mirian Presence the Catholic Church is looking for and we see clearly now the Holy Spirit is the Family of God and Mary is a God and person in being of Power as equal to God in the power of The One God in being in the Trinity together with The Father and The Son for all in The Christ becoming glorified and transfigured with all mankind becoming again One Holy Sprit Family One God in being, OMNILogically.

Peace always,
Stephen
Deliverer of the OMNILogicalGod.Com same God of Abraham expressed in the logic of today.

Firstly, you didn’t mention that you copied and pasted a section from Fr. Mitch Pacwa’s article.

Secondly, regarding Jesus’s statement “Mary can be called the ‘second-born’ of the Father […]”, the explanation behind it wasn’t included in Fr. Mitch Pacwa’s article, alongside his criticism of it. Since you agree with his criticism, care to do what he did not, which is explain why the following “limits the meaning, avoiding evidence of an authentic heresy; but it does not take away the basic impression that she wants to construct a new mariology, which simply goes beyond the limits of propriety”?:

“Mary can be called the Second-born of the Father because, owing to the perfection granted to Her and preserved by Her, and to Her dignity of Spouse and Mother of God and Queen of Heaven, She comes second after the Son of the Father and second in His eternal thought, which ab aeterno took delight in Her.” (Vol. I, pp. 4-5)

Thirdly, regarding Jesus’s statement that Mary would be “second to Peter with regard to ecclesiastical hierarchy […]”, again, the explanation behind it wasn’t included in Fr. Mitch Pacwa’s article, alongside his criticism of it. Since you agree with his criticism, care to do what he did not, which is explain why the following is an “imprecise statement”?:

“During the time that You will remain on the Earth, and You are second to Peter with regard to ecclesiastical hierarchy, he being the Head and You a believer, but first as Mother of the Church having given birth to Me, Who am the Head of this mystical Body?” (Vol. IV, p. 147)

Peace to all,

To me the Mystical Body is the Holy Spirit Family One God in being existing before creation becoming again through the flesh becoming again in both natures, Spirit and Life, God and Temple becoming again through three preexisting powers and separate Gods in being equal each in the Powers of God From Creation through Transformation for Glorification and transfiguration in all becoming Again One Holy Spirit Family One God in being from the Father through The Mother for The Son in The Christ becoming again One Holy Spirit Family One God in being.

Rational logic can now be seen correctly as The Holy Spirit as the Family of God, no gender and now we truthfully see Mary, The Mother of God and Mother of Son of Man from Heaven, the Word is God in The Holy Spirit Family becoming conceived in the flesh of Jesus becoming the Christ through The New Eve and through The Christ becoming again in all One Holy Spirit Family One God in being through both natures.

“It is true that Scripture does not say the first sin of Adam and Eve was a sexual one, but it also doesn’t clearly define what it was. It’s been generally agreed that the description of Adam and Eve eating of the forbidden fruit is a symbol of their sin, of their disobedience, not the actual material object of their sin. The Church has never formally taught what that sin was, so though one is free to disagree with the belief that it was sexual in nature, one cannot claim that belief to be an error.” In Defense of thePoem
By Jonathan A. Baker

To me Baker is not logical and the Poem is illogical to me, good reading but failed in truth, rationally.

Formally the truth can only be know logically. What is the first sin becomes from two natures becoming again. The Tree of Knowledge of Good and Evil brought choice from the Spirit for the souls of all for the flesh to become the image of the Father becoming again One Holy Spirit Family One God in being. The Image of the Holy Family is the One God in being through both natures, Spirit and life.

Adam and Eve are created from the Father eternal mortal with access to the Tree of Life and the Tree of Knowledge. As Authority and Spirit and Life Adam was told not to eat of the Tree of Knowledge, giving access remaining in the Garden with access to the Tree of Life Daily. Adam seen by God as lonely separates Authority an Spirit and Life from the Rib (Greek for equal or whole side) of Adam, creating Eve equal in the Power of the Authority of Adam as Spirit and Life in Eve. Eve defies Authority, Adam and Eve as Spirit and Life gives up her mortal eternal life for the love of Adam to have him know the goodness of life and spirit even if it meant her own death. And now Adam’s choice becomes to choose to live alone forever with out Eve or to die with the Love of Eve.

In all generalization and truthfully logically The Holy Spirit is a Family of God rationally and Mary existed in fulfilled intelligence logic as Queen of Heaven and Mother of God, God of Mercy before creation was ever created was even created, OMNILogically. And intelligently, physically and faithfully through the Immaculate Conception and The New Eve all mankind is transformed into immortality becoming again through The Christ incorruptibly glorified and transfigured One Holy Spirit Family One God in being.

Reasonably, really, Mary is from Adam and Eve, from the Power of The Holy Spirit at the Annunciation becoming the New Eve through the Immortal flesh in the Immaculate Conception delivering through Virgin Birth Jesus conceived by the Holy Spirit Family from the New Adam becoming the Christ in all mankind becoming again through The Transfiguration just like Our Brother Jesus in all mankind glorified and transfigured One Holy Spirit Family One God in being.

Mary is the Miriam Presence the Catholic Church is looking for and we see clearly now the Holy Spirit is the Family of God and Mary is The Mother of God and a person in being of Power as equal to God in the power of The One God in being in the Trinity together with The Father and The Son for all in The Christ becoming glorified and transfigured with all mankind becoming again One Holy Spirit Family One God in being, OMNILogically.

Adam and Eve created love and The New Adam and The New Eve fulfill eternal love through The Passion of the Christ becoming to love only and to love with only the most love becoming again, One Holy Spirit Family One God in being, OMNILogically.

Peace always,
Stephen

Why are you so infatuated with this Maria Valtorta? What is your agenda? What has she revealed to you that you want the world to also believe to be true?

“You looked up Maria Valtorta, found a recent statement by The Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith that her writings “cannot be considered to be of supernatural origin”, and shared it on a public forum without knowing anything else about her. Why do that unless you blindly believe what you read to be true?”

I do not accept the requirement that I investigate a case myself before telling others about a Vatican statement I found. And if I blindly believe what I read, I would accept what you wrote about Maria Valtorta. My quoting a Vatican statement is not a good reason for your harsh criticism.

You forgot the word “alleged” words ; )

Also, the alleged prophet Joseph Smith also claimed to have received visions and was given sacred texts and revelations from God.

Peace to all,

We see all trying to use finite disciplines to understand what cant be understood because the infinite disciplines cannot be grasped by finite minds, rationally.

OMNILogic is from where we ask, rhetorically, why and how are we hearing this.

To me logically the test becomes for example we teach this to a child then have the child explain it to us, then when we take the energy to listen, because we know logically it takes less energy to speak than to listen. I tell this story 11 times a day and the proportions are almost exact correlating, 5 people do not want to hear it, for whatever reason, perhaps because of the energy they may waste listening to it, for we know we cannot judge, and 5 people do not get the logic the first time perhaps, but one person gets The Mind of God through the Logic of the OMNILogical God and becomes that one that can unite all as one in being through the common denominator of all faiths and the common denominator is the spirit and in Catholicism the spirits are preexisting Persons in being Gods in Being From the Father through the Mother for the Son in all becoming The Christ becoming again One Holy Spirit Family One God in being through the Power of the Trinity of Powers in One Holy Spirit Family One God in being. Hopefully with full of energy we may take the time and energy and we will listen to The OMNILogical truth.

To me there is no mystery for all using logic.

We hear all private, and public interpretations, but never true logic, used to be able to see God form finite earth, to me. All say parts of some things but never unite the Ming of God in logic for all to see, until The Delivery of The OMNILogical God by Stephen through teh Power of The Holy Spirit Family One God in being.

Logically, Jesus is God and The Father is God and the Mother is God, and each Gods are preexisting before creation was ever created was even created and each God is separately God making them uncreated and true Gods in being and each God is equal in the Powers of God and together One God One Holy Spirit Family in being.

The Logical Pentecost for all becoming again is from the same Father and the same God of the Two Nature God from the Faith of Abraham expressed in the logic of today.

The Mind of God has to become to mankind through the flesh for the Spirit to become again in a Body nature manifested by the spirit nature through the created soul to become again through the fulfilled logical intelligence in the new being, logically. God wants to share eternal undefiled infallible fulfilled love through spirit for life becoming again in all in One Body, OMNILogically.

Jesus logically brings eternal logical intelligence that never fails in all cases of the fulfilled faith and morality of The One God in being and from the Spirit power of the intelligence becoming The Christ in all mankind becoming again One Holy Spirit Family One God in being.

The Spirit God of Abraham creates the body, creates the soul from the spirit through the soul of the Body for the flesh to become again in both natures from spirit power glorified and transfigured incorruptible through the soul for the manifestation through the flesh transformed becoming immortality for The Two Nature Body, The New Body becoming again, Statically infallibly unfailing dynamically pulsing eternally through fulfilled eternal love from His Passion with no choice but loving only undefiled and loving with only the most love eternally in One Holy Family One God in being, rationally, OMNILogically.

The intelligence of the OMNILogical God is truly Catholic, trusted and verified through all of the Logical Formulas in The Wondrous Mysteries of the Faith through the Christ becoming again in all One Holy Family One God in being.

Peace always,
Stephen

Peace to all,

The Word, The Holy Spirit Family One God in being, became flesh From The New Eve by the Power of The Holy Spirit Family conceived through the Soul Jesus for the New Adam in The Christ becoming again in all mankind One Holy Spirit Family One God in being.

Logically, in all rational thinking, Joseph Smith cannot understand the Two Nature God of Abraham logically and will never be able to explain the Mind of God, with any sense available with His finite mind and using His disciplines of earth, rationally.

I know many religious people and many see Christ’s Mother in many ways. Some of the religious leaders make not much mention of Mary.

Maria Valtorta has no proof Jesus is God only is guessing and not intelligently thinking in all generalization and not judging. We know logically, from the Power of the Holy Spirit Jesus has left behind for all to share through the Advocate, the Entire Wisdom of the Holy Family One God in being from the Cross. We have to understand, The Holy Spirit is not “just” a person. Intelligently rationally and faithfully the Holy Spirit is the Family and preexisting Family of God in three powers of the universe. And only logically we can know through the OMNILogical God, the God of the logic of today, and the Same God from the Father of Faith, Abraham, expressed truly rationally logically for all to be able to see God with New Logical Eyes, OMNILogically.

Logic dictates both trusted and verified through all of the Logical Formulas of the Wondrous Mysteries of the Faith, Jesus is God because The souls conceived through the Flesh of Jesus Virgin Born because the souls of The Family of God preexisted, not requiring blood and water birth because the Souls of the Holy Spirit Family preexisted before creation was ever created was even created. Blood and water birth creates the souls for all created and being logically reborn through flesh in the New Eve and saved from the Holy Spirit in the New Adam in The Christ in all mankind salvation is for all mankind becoming again through the Christ, One Holy Spirit Family One God in being. Joseph Smith cannot understand the Will of The Universe and Nor Maria, The True Mind of Created, becoming and becoming again, One God in being for all, intelligently, rationally and faithfully, without the knowledge of the OMNILogical God. The Eternal Priestly Authority of Spirit and Life preexisted in fulfilled intelligence logic before creation was ever created was even created as The Son and God in being, preexisting existing as God, separately God and with the Father through the Mother are all together One Holy Spirit Family One God in being. The person in being of Jesus is God of Justice and God of Transformation and Glorification for all becoming through the Christ becoming again One Holy Spirit Family One God in being, rationally and faithfully.

Logically, Jesus has already returned and opened the Gates of Heaven from death and resurrection becoming again One Holy Spirit Family One God in being. The Second Coming is the Transfiguration of the New Heaven and Earth in the New Heaven now fulfilled through both natures, Spirit and life.

All mankind is Created From the Father and the first becoming into flesh immortality is transformed from the Mother in the New Eve for The Son in all The New Adam, the Holy Spirit Family Conceived through the flesh of Jesus in Holy Spirit incorruptiuon for all through The Christ, secondly becoming again through both natures in One Incorruptible Holy Spirit Immortal Family One God in being, OMNILogically.

Logically and truthfully, To all who thinks The Transformation into the New Heaven and Earth and for all mankind, Heaven has not happened you are physically, logically wrong, all wrong logically and faithfully, The Second Coming is already finished from the Cross. “It is finished” says Jesus. Jesus is not coming back, because logically He never left us as orphans, Sanctified Baptized and transformed into the Holy Family from Sacrifice through Penance for Atonement and in Communion with Him Comfirmed in the Same becoming again glorified and transfigured in His Family, Our One Holy Spirit Family One God in being, OMNILogically.

Heaven is now open, since 33 A.D., logically.

Peace always,
Stephen
Deliverer of The OMNILogicalGod.Com