I feel like a sham

Sorry if this seems disorganized or flat out doesn’t make sense, or if it doesn’t belong in this forum. I’m just looking to vent some of this to someone, and unfortunately I don’t feel comfortable talking to anyone I know about this.

I am a cradle Catholic. I’ve gone to mass every Sunday for pretty much my entire life, give or take a few sick days here and there. I wear a crucifix around my neck and Catholic paintings adorn my bedroom walls. I take a missal to mass most days and try to follow the readings. My responses in Mass are second nature, like reflex. For the most part, I treat others with respect, and show love to my family and friends.

All these things, however, feel like a cover. I hold the title of “Catholic”, but I do not feel like one at all. I don’t even feel like a Christian. I am so hopelessly obsessed and addicted to worldly desires, specifically pornography. I continue to sin over and over and it’s gotten to the point where I almost don’t feel any shame. It is frequent that I pray to God asking him to take away my desires. I feel like I don’t have the strength to stop and I want him to rid me of the torture I inflict upon myself. I would genuinely be better off if my sexuality just went away.

Every day I knowingly spit on the words of Christ through my hedonistic actions. I pray and go to confession, but it seems like it just keeps getting worse. I know I could probably pray harder and go to confession more frequently, but it’s hard when I feel like I’m getting nothing out of it. I know I’m inflicting this damage myself, but there are times when I almost feel possessed. The faithful part of my soul urging me to stop and listen to Christ is always immediately drowned out by an almost demonic version of my conscience telling me to continue, tempting me away from the virtues that will make me the man I strive to be.

I feel stuck in a loop. I don’t know what to do. I hope God is with me, but I don’t feel him.

1 Like

First, I want to welcome you to the forum. Second, it takes courage to be real about [y]our struggles.

For some, addiction is easy to overcome and for others, it is very difficult. There is as reason why we say that Christ came to free us from our sin. Sin is a form of enslavement. We need His grace to break the chains that sin has on us. The best way to receive this grace is to frequent the Sacrament of Reconciliation. The more you struggle, the more you need to go and the less you will want to go.

The best advice I ever received from someone who has lost hundreds of pounds (and if he can do it, I have no excuse). “When you don’t feel like working out, that is when you need to work out. No excuses!”

The second advice that I heard from a man who was addicted to alcohol was this. “Either you are drinking or you are not.”

I think together, these can apply in your situation. Either you are looking at poґn or you are not. And when you least feel like going to Confession, is when you should go.

This reminds me of a Podcast I listened to a bout a cult. The men and women in the cult took a vow of celibacy (similar to how our Nuns and Priests do). Some of the men felt that they were really struggling with this, so they kept asking the Cult leader if they could castrate themselves. He kept telling them no. But, they were persistent and kept asking until he finally agreed to allow it. One of the women in this cult was a nurse, so they asked her to conduct the procedure. Something went horribly wrong and one of the men’s (without getting too graphic) scrotum began filling with fluids and expanding!

The first thing they did was call a Catholic Priest (even though they had nothing to do with Christianity at all). They explained the situation to the Priest and he informed them that we do not do what they were trying to do. In fact, if you read the First Council of Nicaea (325 AD) they speak against voluntary castration among clergy (except for medical purposes or if someone was castrated by barbarians would not be in violation). They ended up having no choice, but to take the man to the Hospital (who had lots of questions as you would expect : )

St. Paul, who was celibate himself (1 Corinthians 7:7-8), talked about men who were unable to “exercise self-control, they should Marry. For it is better to Marry than to burn with passion” (verse 9).

But, if you are someone who really struggles with the sin of lust, getting Married is not a cure-all! Protestant and Evangelical Pastors being unfaithful in their Marriages happen quite often. We’ve also seen them on “To Catch a Predictor” and an Orthodox Priest just got caught in an undercover sting near us a few months ago. So, one’s disordered desires do not go away when one gets Married.

It is interesting that right after these verses, St. Paul begins talking about how they are not to get divorced. St. Paul knew that even in Marriage, individuals will struggle still with temptation.

Jesus, our Lord, also talks about disordered desires and lust, “I tell you that anyone who looks at a woman lustfully has already committed adultery with her in his heart” (Matthew 5:28).

He goes on to say, “If your right eye causes you to sin, tear it out and throw it away. For it is better that you lose one of your body parts than for your whole body be thrown into hell (verse 29). And if your right hand causes you to stumble, cut it off and throw it away. It is better for you to lose one part of your body than for your whole body to go into hell (verse 30).”

Jesus does not want us literally to cut off body parts (so again, castration is not an option : )

And Jesus also talks against divorce after these verses also. Just an observation.

To make this more relatable, If your iPhone causes you to sin, then cut it off! If you are streaming inappropriate movies or shows, then cut it off. If an app is causing you to sin, delete it!

We cannot serve two masters, “Either you will hate the one and love the other, or you will be devoted to the one and despise the other” (Luke 16:13). Why do you feel like you are an imposter? Because you serve two masters. One master wants to free you, while the other is trying to enslave you. Choose the One who desires to free you from sin and reject the master that enslaves.

The devil is an accuser. First he convinces you to justify a sinful act. Maybe he tells you that if you just do this thing, then the desire to do it will be gone (sure momentarily), but he knows that the disordered desire will return even greater than before. But we buy the lie again and again, until we say “no.” The devil cannot make us do anything. Everything is consent. We consent to sin, even though some are more culpable than others).

After we have fallen for the devil’s lie, he accuses and we begin to label ourselves by this sin we have consented to! We begin to be convinced that we are unforgivable. That we are too shameful to God to be forgiven. These too are lies!

Please let me reframe the way in which you are looking at this. When we were Baptized, we entered into a Covenantal relationship with Jesus, the bridegroom.

In Marriage, we love, we sacrifice, we mature, we forgive, and we are forgiven. Yes, St. Paul and Jesus talk about divorce, but they also talk about Marriage and how we ought to live within a Covenantal relationship. They also talk a lot about perseverance and being persistent. Not to get what we want, like the cult-follower who thought the answer was doing it his way, but rather, being persistent in God’s ways.

Holiness is not us doing works, but Christ working in us! Together, we cooperate with one another. We can never do this alone, nor are we expected to (Ephesians 2:8-9).

Faith is not a feeling. Sure there is times when we feel closer to God than other times. The times I have felt closest to Jesus, are the times when I am least focused on other’s sins and more on my own (Matthew 7:3-5), which then leads to me focusing more on Christ’s Sacrificial love for me, in spite of my sin and what the devil has convinced me I am! Am I a victim of sin or did I consent to sin? God is reaching out to help, now what are we (God my Father, Jesus who frees me, the Holy Spirit, and I) going to do about it?!

Know that my Prayers are with you in moments of temptation, as you Pray, Come Holy Spirit.

Also, I would encourage you to start reading the Bible more. Begin with the New Testament and then you will see Jesus in the Old Testament. When you encounter something that doesn’t make sense or that you may need clarification on, there are some great apps to help you better understand (Catena, Truthly, and Catholic Answers to name a few). Also, The Big Green Catechism has a table in the back where you can look up verses from the Bible and it tells you where in the Catechism that that verse is referenced. I have found this also very helpful. The Bible is a Catholic Book and a love letter from God to His bride, the church (you and I).

Its a battle of the flesh over the Spirit.

Galatians 5:16-17

16 But I say, walk by the Spirit, and you will not gratify the desires of the flesh. 17 For the desires of the flesh are against the Spirit, and the desires of the Spirit are against the flesh, for these are opposed to each other, to keep you from doing the things you want to do.

Stay away from the internet and participate in mass fully especially Communion where we meet the Lord it should be done respectfully.There is a priest there too who you could talk to in confession.Fight the battle through the Holy Spirit and you will become stronger.You have the Holy Spirit that’s why it bothers you so much you know its wrong.Put a picture of Divine Mercy on you phone or laptop.

I have gone through similar battles in my life we all have.

I haven’t read the replies (because Cade’s is quite lengthy), but I do have some advice I can offer.

  1. You state that you do not feel God’s presence with you. I’m going to tell you immediately that it is completely normal to not feel his presence. For 50 years of her life, Mother Teresa of Calcutta did not feel God’s presence. It, logically and just realistically, is impossible to feel him all the time. Most of the time, we don’t even think about God at the fore front of our mind. If you do have concerns about not feeling his presence, though, I would discuss it with a priest. Truthfully, I believe you don’t feel him because you are distracted by the weight of sin you are carrying. Again, completely normal.
  2. I do believe that Reconciliation can help. But, as with everything, it has to be done in moderation. This may seem contradictory, but going to confession can be a bad thing for some people. It’s not the confession that is bad, but more of the mindset. If you are going to confession constantly with the same sin, (1) you will drive yourself insane and (2) you may even lose hope at your salvation from the repeated sin (this is from my own experience). A priest told me this once, in a joking manner, but it remains true. If you feel bad that you keep coming to confession with the same sin, be glad you’re not coming with a different one.
  3. The “demonic version of your conscience” as you call it is the Devil trying to hold you down by sin. Right now, it seems like he has a pretty good hold on you. But, never fear, for a Bible is always near. This is just what I used when I was constantly being tempted by sexual sin (so it may not work for you), but, every time I felt the urge to commit a sin, I would open a random page in the Bible and read until I felt that I could close it and not feel tempted again. You can do this sort of thing with other activities or distractions too.
  4. The faithful part of your soul is, potentially obviously, the good part of you and the Holy Spirit working together to lead you closer to Christ. So, it’s a very good thing that you are able to recognize what it is asking of you.
  5. Sometimes addiction and repeated sinful nature can be helped by “wordly matters”, kind of like AA groups for alcoholics. It’s good that you found a place where you could discuss this. It may be best to find other real world places to talk about this, whether it is in a religious setting or not. It would also be good if you talk to a priest about your struggles. Trust me, they will understand it and they can offer you the best advice.
  6. You said that you feel like you get nothing out of prayer or confession. My question for you is (rhetorical) have you been consistent with those practices? Nothing is immediate. Your problems won’t magically disappear with one prayer or one trip to the confessional. It is going to take hard work, grit, and Jesus to get through this.
  7. You said that you want God to get rid of your sexuality. You stated that you feel that you do not have the strength. But, you’re wrong. God never puts us in situations or challenges that we cannot face with his help. It may feel like God is no where to be found right now, but if you turn back to him and bring your problems to him and the altar, then you’ll see results. He is giving you the tools, every day, to fight this battle against sin. You just need to open yourself up to him to find it. I believe in you.

Thank you all for your responses, I appreciate it greatly. I thought about this topic all day today.

I was able to combat temptation today, and I will try again tomorrow. I think I’m going to begin attending daily Mass.

Another point I want to articulate that I didn’t very well in my original post is that I feel like I don’t really have a good understanding of what God’s relationship with me is supposed to be like.

I’ve sat here typing for a couple of minutes trying to articulate how I feel about this, but I’m really struggling. The more I think about it, I don’t think I have a relationship with God at all. All of the teachings in the Bible about God’s grace, righteousness, forgiveness, love, etc… all goes over my head. Maybe I haven’t given it the attention it deserves.

I now think I can overcome the addiction I have, maybe because God has placed some hope in my heart, but I don’t know where to go from here regarding my relationship with Him. Maybe I’ll speak with my parish priest.

1 Like

Give God thanks! Just know that you will make mistakes and when you do, do not let it define you. Run to Jesus and seek His grace. The longer you wait, and the more you wallow in shame (a biproduct of sin that often hinders us from going to God), the more astringed we become. When Adam & Eve disobeyed God, they hid from God (as if we can hide from God : )

Have you ever read the Gospel of John (all the way through)? If not, or if you have not in a while, might I suggest you begin there. Praying the Psalms is also great. Proverbs is a fun book to read. Hope this helps : )

This is a great point! She referred to this as a “dark night of the soul.”

Jesus says, “Take My yoke upon you… For My yoke is easy and My burden is light.” (Matthew 11:29-30)

Jesus wants to help you carry this load. A yoke (because I did not know what a yoke was most of my life. I thought it was the yellow part of an egg ; ) is a wooden beam that is put around two oxen pulling heavy things and it distributes the weight so that it is easier for the oxen carry the weight.

I am also reminded of how Simon of Cyrene helped Jesus carry His Cross on the way to Calvary when Jesus (fully God yes, but fully man) was truly struggling to carry the heavy beam (for He had been beaten and tortured up unto this point and the worst was yet to come). Jesus invites us into His suffering and He gives our suffering meaning and purpose. We call this redemptive suffering.

Jesus was tempted by the devil in the desert (or wilderness) for 40 days, and by the Holy Spirit was able to overcome it (Matthew 27:32, Mark 15:21, and Luke 23:26).

When we are in a sort of wilderness of our own, we can learn from our Lord’s example. He fasted, He remembered Sacred Scripture, and He put God’s will over immediate physical needs.

Scrupulosity is a real thing, and generally the individual identifies themselves by their sin. They focus on it obsessively and more than they look to Jesus. The individual harps on what they have done and fails to recognize what Jesus has done for them and is doing in them.

This is one extreme, but the other extreme is when someone fails to recognize their sin and acts entitled or deserving of God’s forgiveness.

The reality is that none of us deserves what Christ has done and does for us, but He did it for you, because He loves you! And He loves me. This is relationship. When you do something that hurts your relationship, you come to that person and you seek reconciliation. And if someone comes to you with a contrite heart, and you forgive them. And you might even do something for someone, even though they do not deserve it. This is what Jesus has done and does for us!

I agree. What a gift!

Also agree. Repeated behavior (bad or good) becomes a habit. In AA they might encourage you to remove yourself from places where you are tempted (bars, parties, etc.) if you have really low impulse control.

I think this is good advice also. If you are tempted to view sinful content, then remove yourself from the area that houses this temptation. This might be taking a walk or exercising. Something to redirect your thoughts and attention. Go visit or call your Grandma : )

I too believe in you! : ) And I trust that Jesus will help you through this if you invite Him into your struggles! I think what you will find is that as you distance yourself from the immediate temptation that you will find that it will be come easier over time. Form good habits in place of the bad. You’ve got this. Again, you may make mistakes, but get back up and let Jesus help you.