Both Pope Francis and many Republicans are saying politics > their Christian Faith. Please allow me to explain.
- Pope Francis confuses policy for virtue.
- Republicans demonize migrants collectively.
You can support deportation & Ex. 22:21; Lev. 19:33-34.
These verses speak to how Christians should treat other individual (“aliens”). It is not speaking about policy. Pope Francis (and some Bishops) do not understand this.
Exodus 22:21 says, “Do not mistreat an alien or oppress him, for you [faithful] were aliens in Egypt.”
“'When an alien lives with you in your land, do not mistreat him…” — Leviticus 19:33-34. It does not say legally or illegally.
Pope Francis often puts his politics before truth. I would point out to him that Italy (in which Rome is the capital) is also in the Top Ten Deporting Countries in 2025.
Republicans, many, talk about illegal immigrants as though they are all violent criminals. Some are. Many are not.
I saw one commenter on Twitter say, “Immigration or invasion?” Both. Not every individual coming here illegally is doing so for the same reasons. Some are being orchestrated to come here, being used as pawns for someone else’s political ends. But some are not. This does not mean they should not be deported. If I were in another Country illegally, I would expect to be deported (Golden Rule).
I was at my Men’s Bible Study a couple weeks back and the debate about Immigration was heating up, while President Trump’s administration began focusing heavily on deporting individuals here illegally. This was also the same week that a commercial plane collided with a helicopter, killing young U.S. figure skaters among others. A gentleman in our Bible Study joked that “we” should put the illegals on American Airlines (the implication being that individuals who are being deported would be killed). I like a dark joke as much as anyone, but this one bothered me. Maybe it was because we were at a Bible Study. Or maybe because the rhetoric coming form the political Right was painting all illegals as violent criminals, which is not the case.
We had a guy in our city, who was here illegally, shoot three people at a local bar. One of the men who was killed was an off-duty police officer, husband, and a father. It was super sad. Some individuals here illegally are violent criminals.
There are also reports that some illegals being orchestrated to come here were released from prisons and mental institutions in other countries. If true, this is concerning.
Some come here illegally intently of the large caravans. Meaning they are not part of what some on the Right refer to as an “orchestrated inversion.”
Others, who are not violent, came here legally and their visa’s ran out, which changes their status to illegal. As I said, they too should expect to be deported, but to lump these individuals with violent criminals is uncharitable.
We are discovering that under President Biden, tax dollars were going to support individuals here illegally. This would please Pope Francis I’m sure. Assuming this is true, I think it is insane, but then again, I’m a Libertarian who thinks outsourcing our Christian duty to government is a horrible idea. For one, it glorifies government, not God. It leads individual to worship government over God.
I know to many what I am saying sounds like a contradiction, but it is not. God calls Christians to love others and to pray for those who hate us. One can be against the evil’s of abortion and yet, still treat individuals who have either had an abortion or is contemplating abortion with compassion and human dignity. When Republicans refer to everyone who has had an abortion as a violent “murderer,” even though the reality is that they payed someone to violently snuff out the life of an innocent unborn child, we are still called to love these individuals. It does not mean that we demand government to do it for us.
Not a perfect analogy, but I do see some other parallels, between abortion and the topic of deportation.
Libertarian philosopher, Murray N. Rothbard, compared an unwanted pregnancy to finding a stowaway on an airplane. He argued that you have the right to eject this intruder from your plane. But, his friend Fr. James Sadowsky, wrote a letter in response, essentially saying wouldn’t it be better to land the plane rather than removing the uninvited individual in such an inhumane way that would ultimately destroy his/her life?
The way in which one deports an uninvited individual matters. And The Bible says the way you and I treat an “alien” matters.