SUGGESTION: Category Topic - Pinned "About" Posts Suggested Edits

Site Feedback
1

CATHOLICTALK FORUM SUGGESTIONS:

I’ve noticed that an overwhelming majority of the Categories topics “About” pinned posts are without description.

Here’s a screenshot example of just one of many:

2026-06-28 19 40 06
2026-06-28 19 40 061133×543 90.1 KB

These pinned posts are the Discourse** default** and desperately need revision so as to help Users of that particular Topic for:

A description and explanation of the Category topic would be helpful by providing clear and concise explanation so as to Stay-on-Topic for posts within that Category Topic.

Possibly assign a Category Topic moderator with a link to the Moderator’s profile.

A link to forum Guidelines so that Users know exactly what is and isn’t acceptable or appropriate post content.

A link to Discourse Terms of Service (TOS) which govern the use of the Forum.

A maybe a list to links of Similar Category Topics in which Users should be pointed to for consideration creating posts in the appropriate Topic (which also would help our Moderators spending unnecessary moderation time to police the forum).

I hope this is helpful. TY. +

2

Follow-up:

Here’s a sample (below), generated by Google Gemini AI (which I’ve slightly edited) to help by suggesting the editing our APOLOGETICS category topic pinned post.

…

The Apologetics Discussion forum, designed to be clear, welcoming, and structured for community guidelines.

About Our Community

Welcome to CatholicTalk - Apologetics, a premier online community dedicated to the thoughtful exploration, defense, and discussion of the Catholic Christian faith. Whether you are a seasoned apologist, a curious seeker, a believer looking to strengthen your faith, or a skeptic with honest questions, there is a place for you at our table.

Our Mission

Our goal is to fulfill the exhortation of 1 Peter 3:15: “to always be prepared to give a defense to anyone who asks for a reason for the hope that is in us, yet to do so with gentleness and respect.”

We aim to bridge the gap between rigorous intellectual inquiry and deep spiritual devotion.

What We Discuss

We dive into a wide range of Apologetics topics, including but not limited to:

  • Existence of God: Cosmological, teleological, moral, and ontological arguments.

  • Reliability of Scripture: Historical reliability, textual criticism, and archaeology.

  • The Resurrection: Evaluating the historical evidence for the resurrection of Jesus.

  • Problem of Evil: Engaging with theological and philosophical responses to suffering.

  • Science and Faith: Exploring the relationship between modern science, creation, and evolution.

  • Catholic Doctrine

  • Articles of Faith

  • Nicene Creed

  • etc…

Community Guidelines & Etiquette

To maintain a high standard of dialogue, we ask all members to adhere to our core community principles:

1. Truth Over Winning

Our primary objective is the pursuit of truth, not scoring intellectual points. Approach every conversation with humility and a willingness to learn.

2. Radical Respect

We welcome diverse perspectives and serious pushback. However, attacks on character (ad hominem), mockery, and blanket generalizations are strictly prohibited. Attack the argument, respect the person.

3. Substantiate Your Claims

Back up your assertions with evidence, whether textual, historical, or philosophical. Avoid hit-and-run assertions or low-effort trolling.

A Note to Skeptics and Seekers: You do not need to share our faith to participate. Honest doubts and tough questions are not tolerated here—they are encouraged. All we ask is that your inquiries are brought in good faith.

Get Started

Ready to join the conversation?

  1. Introduce yourself in the [Welcome Thread].

  2. Check out our pinned [Resource Guide] for recommended reading.

  3. Dive into an ongoing debate or start your own topic in the appropriate sub-forum.

Let’s reason together.