I’ve worked for more than half a dozen Catholic apostolates and half a dozen Catholic churches. Something that shook me early on in my career, and now seems very obvious, is that Catholic apostolates and churches operate like businesses. They are going to make business decisions about staffing, benefits, book deals, performance etc…
We want to romanticize Catholic organizations and frame them like the Early Christian Church living in community and providing for each other’s needs. That’s just not how this works.
Similarly, we want to expect sacrificial behaviors from employees of Catholic organizations. We expect them to work at sacrificial salaries of 60% of the industry standard for their work because of the mission. We expect them to work beyond their normal contract for the mission. We also expect them to be more virtuous and to be more reasonable than the average person.
Both of these ideas are false. Catholic organizations are going to make standard business decisions, and Catholic employees are going to have all the same concerns and expectations as they would at any other job.
We shouldn’t read into the Trent Horn separation as a scandal. 1,000 other Catholics separated from their Catholic jobs last week for perfectly normal reasons. And we should pray for his success, and for Catholic Answers’ success in advancing the evangelistic mission of the Gospel.
But what’s your take?