Can Catholics Celebrate Halloween?

Halloween, or All Hallows’ Eve is fundamentally a celebration of the Vigil of All Saints Day. Centuries-old traditions, especially from Ireland, encouraged children to dress up to mock the Devil as the Church prepared to celebrate everyone in heaven who escaped his clutches. Irish families carved faces into turnips to scare away evil spirits. However, today the holiday is completely profane. Demonic costumes and activities on Halloween celebrate the evil instead of mocking it, as the tradition started. So how far is too far? Can a good Catholic participate in Halloween, and what does that look like?

Simple answer, no. Because it could come across as celebrating evil.

While Halloween does point to monsters being evil and so scary, without unnecessary dimming of that dividing line between good and evil, people threatened with ‘trick or treat’ appears aggressive and what we know of Satan from Catholicism, it almost suggests possession of those dressing up.

Any history which you have put forward behind the day is all but forgotten and St. Paul even gave up eating meat because he thought his actions could possibly scandalize in certain situations.

[ I don’t happen to like what is overly settled sea-dwelling Irish folklore; one can give or take what they put forward in regards to customs. ]

The children and parents are having fun and so not giving sweets could bring some heartache, while I think in this instance it is seeming cruel to be kind.

All Hollows Eve always brings out the overly scrupulous.

1 Like

As has been mentioned, Halloween arises out of the calendar of the Church. Even if some people are abusing the day, it does not mean that we must refuse to observe it.

We don’t refuse to observe every Christmas custom that takes place outside of a church just because Christmas is twisted toward consumerism and people have replaced Christ with Santa Claus (etc.).

There may be some specific practices we should not adopt. For example, if dressing up as the devil seems to glorify the devil, it would probably be best not to do that specific thing.

Other than avoiding anything that seems imprudent, I would suggest finding ways to make the faith more central to the day.

One suggestion from Charles Coloumbe is to bring back “souling”. Trick or treating, he said, came from the practice of children going to people’s houses to ask for soul cakes. In return for receiving one of these cakes, they would pray for the souls of the departed family members of those who gave the cakes.

2 Likes

-------- WARNING --------

If you live alone in a remote area, are easily scared or have suffered at any point in life problems of the mind then DO NOT watch this:

Halloween mask trio allegedly threaten to break down Virginia woman’s door | Fox News

-------- WARNING OVER --------

I can really see how Halloween inspires the same lovely events as Christmas. If I had been a gun owner in the US, around the date they entered that house, those three men wouldn’t be alive today.

By the way, I had a really special moment in the approach towards Christmas some years ago with my mother and it involved a Santa truck with some gospel singers who sang a (Christian) carol just as we were walking past (I think it was something really holy, like ‘Away In A Manger’); Santa, while maybe a little overdone with merchandising and house decorations, stems from true accounts of St. Nicholas.

I don’t see the correlation between the two celebrations.

Father Richard Simon, writing as “Rev. Know-It-All,” said, “You can encourage your children to dress as super-heroes and even saints.” He would not forbid Halloween in moderation to children. He "would forbid it to adults. Halloween has become an adult holiday, with all the attendant debauchery and drunkenness. An unhealthy fixation on things occult seems to be growing, not on the part of children but on the part of parents and older siblings.…
“I think it is far more dangerous for adults and older teens to focus on the morbid and occult movies, costume parties, and what is up with the current popularity of sex vampires? We Catholics are the possessors of supernatural realities: resurrection and spiritual warfare and the casting out of demons. These things really happen in the Catholic faith.”

1 Like

North Americans must have a different idea as to modern concepts behind Halloween because the day in this country is separate from All Souls. There is no correlation. Celebrated on different days, with Halloween being a complete disconnect. All Souls (and All Saints) Day near to Halloween almost shouts out the gulf between popular past-times and attention paid to holy things (Halloween is just a macabre celebration and which suits more as a general rule the scathing attitudes of the English than North Americans).

Another day which is sick, is Fireworks / Bonfire / Guy Fawkes Night. Tortured to death, when trying to rid England of a dictator king. Typical.

And another is Valentine’s Day and which is (or has been turned into, at least) a day of sentimental garbage.

What would sum up the problem, would be Pots and Pans Day instituted to celebrate being common (and which I view as a quite inherent vulgarity of attitude, e.g. toilet humour). The idea is that commonality is converted, not idealised and turned into an idol.

Apart from Christmas and Easter and special days in the Church calendar, the ‘UK’ doesn’t celebrate any national days which I would want anything to do with.

I don’t even wish to stand with everyone alongside, on Poppy Day, and not because the honouring of those who fought against evil shouldn’t be brought to mind, but because I know full well of the proudful bigotry in this country that is the real reason people are standing silent for three minutes. Again, not that three minutes shouldn’t be kept in still silence but rather that one chooses one’s company in going about the activities we undertake. I could happily give my own remembrance at another time. And in another way, if I so please. There is no obligation, necessarily, except not being quiet could (as could the non-existence of a poppy) cause scandal as the ignorant may attribute rudeness, i.e. one is being quiet for them, as much as for those who died during war-time.


(During the pandemic, in the ‘UK’, the population, in ommision of those who saw it as indecorous, and doubled with the fact that I wouldn’t be gaining back funds lost from ruining quality cookware, stood on their door-steps banging their…pots and pans…while some of us took to refraining from the sycophantry with consequential vomit induced nausea, a percentage of the population meanwhile having contracted Sars 2 running out of breath with blood being choked up from their lungs, radio propadanda blurting out, “Save the NHS”, when hospitals couldn’t do anything about the virus anyway because the virus is or was…a virus…as opposed to a bacterial infection).